Rifnote Loading your desk
How a 17-year-old died of a rare breast cancer, and the guidance now named after her

How a 17-year-old died of a rare breast cancer, and the guidance now named after her

Share:

A teenager who died of a rare and aggressive breast tumour has given her name to new national guidance for GPs in Scotland, following a year-long campaign by her parents.

Isla Sneddon, from Airdrie, Lanarkshire, died in March 2025, aged 17. Her diagnosis came two years after she first went to the doctor with a lump in her breast.

Isla’s mother, Michelle Sneddon, 48, said Isla was 15 when she found the lump. “When she was 15, she came down the stairs and was like, ‘I’ve got a lump’, she let me feel her lump and I panicked,” she said. “It felt really quite large, but I played it down and told her it would be fine, I phoned the doctors and they saw her, but because of her age, seeming fit and healthy…”

Isla first went to the GP in July 2022 with a lump in her breast, which was dismissed as benign and due to hormonal changes. Her concerns were repeatedly put down to anxiety and hormones. When she was eventually referred, the breast clinic downgraded the referral from “urgent” to “routine” because of her age.

Twenty-four months after her first appointment, she was diagnosed with a rare sarcoma that had spread to her heart, lungs and lymph nodes. The tumour was identified as Cystosarcoma Phyllodes, a rare and aggressive breast tumour. She died six months after her diagnosis.

How rare is breast cancer in teenagers?

Breast cancer is extremely rare in teenagers. Most breast changes are due to hormonal fluctuations or other harmless causes. When teens do develop breast cancer, it is often an aggressive type.

Children and adolescents account for around 0.1 percent of all breast cancer diagnoses. Risk factors for breast cancer in adolescents include having received chest-wall radiation and having a family history of breast cancer.

Isla’s tumour was of an even rarer kind. According to a published case study, non-epithelial tumors of the breast are extremely rare and have an incidence of less than 1%. The most common non-epithelial breast tumor is the phyllodes tumor.

None of the reports say what caused Isla’s cancer.

“Something she’d grow out of”

Her father, Mark Sneddon, 55, said Isla’s age counted against her. “We believe that if Isla had been an adult presenting with the same symptoms, there would be a lot more done,” he said. “There would have been a longer investigation, she wouldn’t have been told it was something she’d grow out of.”

The couple said: “We cannot change what happened to Isla but knowing that her legacy could help another child to receive the investigations, diagnosis and treatment they need sooner gives us a purpose to keep going.

“Our hope is that Isla’s Principles become more than guidance on a piece of paper. We want them to create lasting change in how children and young people with concerning symptoms are listened to, investigated, and referred.”

What Isla’s Principles say

The guidance has the backing of the Scottish Government and will be used in all health boards in Scotland. The four actions spell out her name:

  • Intuition: doctors should use their professional judgement.
  • Share: information should be shared between primary and secondary care.
  • Look beyond the obvious: doctors should look further when a diagnosis is hard to reach.
  • Agree a plan: doctors should agree a plan with the young person in case the diagnosis proves wrong.

Health Secretary Angela Constance said the guidance was “developed to support earlier and more accurate diagnosis of cancers in children and young people.”

Dr Sal Peterson, co-chair of the Scottish Primary Care Cancer Group, said: “Isla’s Principles are an important addition to existing guidance. They highlight the importance of GP intuition, especially in people with vague symptoms.”

Neil Gray MSP met the family when he was health secretary. He said: “What Isla and her parents went through was horrific and I couldn’t imagine what they experienced. But Mark and Michelle have campaigned tirelessly for this change, and I am so glad to see Isla’s Principles come into effect in the hope that no other young person has the same experience that they did.”

The family is also campaigning for Isla’s Law. It would require urgent paediatric referrals to meet the same maximum waiting times as adult cancer referrals. Their petition has more than 43,000 signatures.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign in to My Weblist